If you are deep into a Franchise Mode run in MLB The Show 26, you already know how brutal a 162-game season can be on your pitching staff. Between random durability dips and the grueling summer schedule, keeping your arms fresh is a constant battle. A six-man rotation is the perfect solution to keep your pitchers out of the fatigue zone, prevent injuries, and give your top prospects some much-needed big-league experience.
The problem? The game’s menu logic natively limits the starting rotation slot to exactly five players. There is no magic button in the coaching staff menu to toggle on a six-man staff.
Fortunately, you can easily bypass this restriction using a couple of manual workarounds. By leveraging your bullpen slots and managing game-day selections, you can run a flawless six-man rotation. Here is exactly how to set it up and run it, whether you play every game or prefer to simulate.
The 6-Man Roster Setup
Before executing any strategy, you need to configure your active 26-man roster properly.
First, call up your sixth starter. Make sure you have six capable starting pitchers on your active roster. Next, assign your standard rotation by filling slots 1 through 5 as you normally would. Finally, place your sixth starting pitcher into the bullpen. Specifically, drop them into one of your Long Relief (LRP) slots.
Once your roster is configured, choose one of the two management methods below depending on your playstyle.
Method 1: The Play or Quick Manage Strategy
If you manually play your games, use Quick Manage, or love to jump in during critical situations, managing a six-man rotation on game day is incredibly straightforward.
When you advance to your next game and reach the team selection and lineup screen, do not simply press past the pitcher selection. Instead of picking the default scheduled starter that the game recommends, take control manually.
Look at your staff and choose whoever is fully rested, or cycle down to your bullpen menu on that exact screen to select your sixth starter from the Long Relief slot. The game will treat them as the official starting pitcher for that game. Because you manually subbed them in, the five pitchers in your regular rotation get an extra calendar day off, allowing them to naturally regenerate maximum stamina and keep their pitch location sharp.
Method 2: The Sim-Rotation Strategy
If you prefer simulating weeks or months at a time, leaving your sixth starter in the bullpen will not work. The AI simulation logic will simply ignore them and run your standard five-man rotation into the ground. To get around this, use the "Start 1, Rest 4" menu swap method.
Start by letting Pitchers 1 through 5 make their consecutive starts as normal. Before the sixth game of the cycle, open up your Pitching Staff menu. Take your Pitcher 1—who is now fully rested and scheduled to start again—and temporarily drop them into the Long Relief bullpen slot.
Next, move your sixth starter out of the bullpen and into the active number 1 rotation slot. Advance to the schedule and simulate that single game. The AI will start your sixth pitcher without issue. Once the game finishes, simply go back into the menus and reverse the swap so your normal rotation can resume.
Pros and Cons of Running a 6-Man Rotation
Before committing to this strategy for an entire season, it helps to weigh the competitive trade-offs.
On the positive side, stamina recovery is massive. Giving your starters extra rest keeps them out of the dangerous yellow and red fatigue zones, ensuring their attributes remain high and their pitches stay sharp. It is also an exceptional tool for prospect growth, allowing you to give a young, high-potential arm consistent Major League innings to boost their development. Furthermore, lowering individual workloads drastically cuts down on injury risks over a long season.
However, there are a few drawbacks to keep in mind. The biggest issue is user maintenance; if you simulate a lot, it requires constant manual menu adjustments between simulation blocks. Carrying a sixth starter also shrinks your available bullpen depth from eight active relievers down to seven, which can hurt if your starters don't go deep into games. Lastly, because you are spreading 162 starts across six pitchers instead of five, your elite ace will log fewer total starts on the year, which might hurt their chances in close Cy Young award races.